Shin Tae-yong's Controversial Reign as Indonesia National Team Coach: Tactical Blunders and Elkan Baggott Saga

Shin Tae-yong's tenure as Indonesia's national team coach has been marked by a series of controversies that have raised questions about his tactics and management style.

One of the most contentious issues has been Shin's alleged tactical blunders. Critics have accused him of making poor decisions during matches, such as fielding an unbalanced team or failing to adapt to the opposition's tactics. These criticisms have been particularly vocal after Indonesia's disappointing performances in recent tournaments, including the 2020 AFF Championship and the 2023 Asian Cup qualifiers.

Another controversy that has plagued Shin's tenure is the ongoing saga surrounding defender Elkan Baggott. Baggott, who plays for Ipswich Town in England, has been a key player for Indonesia but has often been unavailable for national team duty due to club commitments. Shin has been criticized for his handling of the situation, with some accusing him of not doing enough to secure Baggott's release for international matches.

Despite the controversies, Shin has also had some success as Indonesia's coach. He led the team to the final of the 2020 AFF Championship and has overseen the development of several young players. However, the controversies surrounding his tenure have cast a shadow over his achievements and raised questions about his long-term suitability for the role.